I've been using the Ninja Creami long enough to have strong opinions about it. The machine is excellent. But which Ninja Creami you should buy (Regular, Deluxe, or Swirl) depends on what you plan to make with it. Let me break it down.
Save This Recipe 💌
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
Jump to:
- How the Ninja Creami Actually Works
- All Three Models at a Glance
- Ninja Creami Regular: The One That Started It All
- Ninja Creami Deluxe: More Programs, Bigger Batches
- Ninja Swirl by Creami: For the Soft Serve Fans
- The Stuff Nobody Tells You
- What to Make First
- Tips for Best Results
- FAQ
- More Ninja Creami Recipes to Try
- Did you try this recipe?
How the Ninja Creami Actually Works
Before we get into which model, here's what all three have in common: you make a base, freeze it for 24 hours, then let the machine process it into ice cream.
That's it. No churning while you wait. No frozen bowl you have to pre-freeze. You prep your base the night before, come back the next day, and the machine does its thing in about 2-5 minutes.
The result is ultra-smooth, creamy, and fully customizable. That's the whole appeal.
One thing to know upfront: all three machines are loud. Think power drill for 2-5 minutes. It's not a dealbreaker, but don't plan to run it at midnight.
All Three Models at a Glance
| Regular (NC301) | Deluxe (NC501) | Swirl (NC701) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Programs | 7 | 11 | 13 |
| Container size | 16 oz | 24 oz | 24 oz (Swirl-specific) |
| Soft serve dispenser | No | No | Yes |
| Frozen drinks / slushies | No | Yes | No |
| CreamiFit (protein) | No | No | Yes |
| Smoothie Bowl setting | Yes | No | No |
| Price range | $ | $$ | $$$ |
| Counter space | Compact | Moderate | Large |
One important note that trips people up: containers are not interchangeable between models. Regular pints don't fit the Deluxe, Deluxe pints don't fit the Swirl. If you're upgrading, you're starting your container collection from scratch.
Ninja Creami Regular: The One That Started It All
The original model is still a completely solid machine. Seven programs: Ice Cream, Lite Ice Cream, Gelato, Sorbet, Milkshake, Smoothie Bowl, and Mix-In. That covers most of what people actually make.
The 16 oz container is smaller than the Deluxe, which means one pint per sitting rather than a bigger batch. For one or two people, that's usually fine. For a family or anyone who likes variety in the freezer, you'll feel the limit.
The Smoothie Bowl setting is actually exclusive to the Regular. The Deluxe dropped it when they added the frozen drink programs. If you're into smoothie bowls specifically, that's worth knowing.
If you're new to the Ninja Creami and not sure you'll use it weekly, start here. It's the most approachable entry point, and it makes excellent ice cream. My beginner-friendly Ninja Creami recipes are all designed to work on this model.
Buy the Regular if: you're a solo cook or couple, counter space matters, you're budget-conscious, or you mostly want classic scoopable ice cream and sorbet.
Skip it if: you have a family and want bigger batches, you want frozen drinks, or you're eyeing protein ice cream as your main use case.
Ninja Creami Deluxe: More Programs, Bigger Batches
The Deluxe bumps you up to 11 programs and a 24 oz container. That extra size matters more than it sounds. It's roughly 50% more ice cream per spin, which adds up fast when you're making multiple flavors.
The four programs the Deluxe adds over the Regular are the ones that make it feel like an upgrade: Italian Ice, Frozen Drink, Slushi, and Creamiccino (basically a Frappuccino at home). If frozen drinks are appealing to you, this is the only model in the lineup that makes them.
What it gives up: the Smoothie Bowl setting. If that was a draw for you, it's gone on this model.
The Deluxe is my personal pick for most people. The bigger container, the frozen drink programs, and the sturdier build make it worth the price difference over the Regular for anyone who plans to use it regularly. I've made everything from ube ice cream to matcha latte ice cream to lychee ice cream in mine, and the larger pint size never feels like too much.
Buy the Deluxe if: you're cooking for a family, you want frozen drinks and slushies, or you plan to use the machine several times a week.
Skip it if: counter space is tight, you want soft serve specifically, or the Swirl is in your budget.
Ninja Swirl by Creami: For the Soft Serve Fans
The Swirl is a different animal. It has 13 programs, split between scoopable and soft serve options. The scoopable side works just like the other Creami models. The new side, literally the left side of the machine, has a lever that dispenses your processed ice cream as swirled soft serve into a bowl or cone.
It also adds CreamiFit, a dedicated protein ice cream setting that turns a plain protein shake into a scoop-worthy frozen dessert. If the high-protein, lower-calorie ice cream trend is your thing, this setting is genuinely impressive.
Here's the honest trade-off: the Swirl is significantly larger than the other two models. We're talking about a machine that may not fit under your kitchen cabinets. It weighs around 20 lbs. It comes with only two pints, and those pints are exclusive to the Swirl and cost more to replace. And it runs at around 84-91 decibels, which is the loudest of the three.
The soft serve experience is real and it's fun, but reviewers consistently note it doesn't quite replicate a commercial soft serve machine. It melts faster than the kind you'd get at a DQ. If that expectation is managed, most people love it.
At roughly $350, it's almost double the Deluxe. That's a meaningful price difference for what comes down to a soft serve lever and the CreamiFit setting.
Buy the Swirl if: soft serve is the main draw, you're into protein ice cream, you have counter space to spare, and the budget isn't a concern.
Skip it if: you mostly want scoopable ice cream, you have a small kitchen, or the price makes you wince.
The Stuff Nobody Tells You
A few practical things worth knowing before you buy:
- The 24-hour freeze applies to all three. You cannot make ice cream same-day on any Creami model. Plan ahead. Once you're in the habit of keeping a frozen pint or two ready, it's seamless, but the first week always catches people off guard.
- Containers don't cross over. Regular pints (16 oz) only work on the Regular. Deluxe pints (24 oz) only work on the Deluxe. Swirl pints are their own format and only work on the Swirl. If you want variety in the freezer, you'll want to buy extra pints for whichever model you choose.
- Re-spin is your friend. If your ice cream comes out crumbly on the first spin, just run it again. That fixes it almost every time.
- Clean it right after use. The paddle assembly is easy to clean when it's fresh. Leave it and you'll regret it.
What to Make First
Whichever model you land on, these are the flavors worth trying first. If you're new to the Ninja Creami, start simple. Classic vanilla or mango ice cream will show you exactly what the machine can do without any complicated prep. Once you're comfortable, that's when the real fun starts.
For Filipino and Asian flavors, the Ninja Creami is where it gets exciting. Ube ice cream made at home tastes better than anything you'll find at a store. Thai tea ice cream takes about 10 minutes of prep. Jackfruit ice cream is one that will genuinely surprise you.
If you're on the protein ice cream path, the cottage cheese ice cream recipes are a solid starting point and work on any model.
Tips for Best Results
These apply to all three machines:
- Start cold. Use cold ingredients when you prep your base. It improves the final texture.
- Don't overfill. Fill to the Max Fill line, not past it. Every time.
- Taste your base before freezing. It should be slightly sweeter than you want the final product to be, because freezing dulls sweetness a little.
- Freeze flat. Make sure your pint is level in the freezer so the base freezes evenly.
- Re-spin if needed. One extra spin fixes crumbly texture almost every time.
FAQ
No. The containers are different sizes and are not interchangeable. Regular pints are 16 oz, Deluxe pints are 24 oz. Swirl pints are a completely separate format.
No. The Smoothie Bowl setting is only on the Regular. The Deluxe replaced it with the frozen drink programs.
Depends entirely on whether soft serve and the CreamiFit setting are priorities for you. If scoopable ice cream is mostly what you want, the Deluxe is the better value by a significant margin.
All three are loud. The Swirl has been measured at 84-91 decibels during processing. Plan your timing accordingly.
Yes, for all ice cream and sorbet programs across all three models. Milkshake programs on some models are an exception and don't require pre-freezing.
The Swirl has a dedicated CreamiFit setting designed for it. The Deluxe and Regular don't have that specific setting, but both can make protein ice cream using the Lite Ice Cream setting with good results.
The Deluxe. The 24 oz container gives you more per spin, and the price is reasonable compared to the Swirl.
More Ninja Creami Recipes to Try
Did you try this recipe?
Share how it turned out in the comment box below, and if you loved it, share it on Facebook, Pinterest & Instagram.
Thank you!
Thank you for your feedback 😊